Humanitarian Studies Colloquium: The Ethics of Humanitarian Action – rationale and critique of a do-gooder regime

Bjørn Heidenstrøm / Dadaab Refugee camp 2010

Date/Time: 27/11/2017  12:00 - 14:00

Location: PRIO

On 27 November, the Norwegian Centre for Humanitarian Studies, the Law and Ethics Research Group and the Humanitarianism Research Group at PRIO  will host the fifth Humanitarian Studies Colloquium focusing on ethics. A light lunch will be served.

The Humanitarian Studies Colloquium is a quarterly forum for scholarly discussion of methodological and thematic issues in the emergent field of humanitarian studies, taking place at PRIO. The Colloquium is organized in collaboration with the Humanitarianism Research Group at PRIO, and is open to invited participants.  The disciplinary focuses of past colloquiums included history, the sociology of law, anthropology, and media.

Background

The disciplinary focus of this fifth colloquium will be ethics.

The morality of humanitarian action is hard to reject, yet humanitarian practice is subject to substantive controversy. On the one hand, humanitarian law and relief are criticized for not being sufficiently efficient, comprehensive, and ambitious. On the other, it is criticized for being overly intrusive, culturally insensitive and wedded to power. Humanitarianism itself is torn between duty based and consequentialist ethics, and general theories of global justice leave little hope for humanitarianism to resolve the problem of human suffering. In Norway, these tensions have surfaced in debates on “the do-gooder regime” (godhetsregimet), where development aid, refugee policies and military interventions with a humanitarian justification have been characterized as naïve, incoherent, or counterproductive, blinded by a missionary urge to save strangers. The repercussions of this debate for humanitarian law and relief nonetheless remain to be systematically discussed.

In this fifth colloquium, the ethical premises of scholarly debate on humanitarianism will be considered with the objective of clarifying the potential contribution of ethics to humanitarian studies.

Program

12:00 – Welcome

  • Kristin Bergtora Sandvik (PRIO/ UiO)

12:10 – Introduction to the ethics of humanitarian action

  • Kristoffer Lidén (PRIO)

12:20 – Presentations: Elements for a research agenda

  • Odin Lysaker (UiA/UiO), Three Cases of Humanitarian Ethics: Health, Migration, and Climate
  • Sidsel Roaldkvam (UiO), The Politics of Life
  • Alejandra Mancilla (UiO), When Basic Rights are Just Claims, and this is Unjust
  • Camilla Serck-Hanssen (UiO), The Ethical Challenge of Civilian Contractors
  • Lars Christie (UiO), Ethical Challenges for Humanitarian Assistance in Fragile States
  • Kristian Bjørkdahl (UiO), The Mediation of Humanitarian Ethics

13:30 – 14:00 – Discussion

Please contact amacel@prio.org with any questions. Deadline for registration is 24 November at noon.

Loading Map....